Panettone Season: The Christmas Bread Sicilian Bakers Do Better Than Anyone

By Nando & Rose Benincasa, Founders of Castanea Sicilian Cafe
You can buy panettone online and have it shipped anywhere in the United States, and the loaves worth ordering are the ones made with a natural mother yeast and a slow, patient rise. That is what gives panettone its tall dome, featherlight crumb, and deep buttery perfume. Sicilian bakers took a northern Italian classic and made it their own, and in our family a slice has become as much a part of Christmas morning as the espresso pot.
The smell of panettone in a bakery at Christmas is a little like coming home: warm butter, sweet citrus, and a golden loaf slowly cooling while the holiday table waits. Panettone has its roots in Milan, but the island bakers who love it most have long since made it their own.
Both of our Los Angeles cafes carry panettone through the holidays, and both take order ahead: Beverly Hills and Venice Beach. If you are shopping from outside LA, our online market ships nationwide.
What makes panettone different from other Christmas breads?
Panettone is not simply a sweet bread shaped like a tall dome. Its character comes from lievito madre (natural mother yeast) and a long, careful fermentation. Artisan Sicilian bakers may let their dough rise for 24 to 72 hours, sometimes feeding the starter in stages over several days.
That time matters. The enriched dough, made with butter and egg yolks, develops a soft, tender crumb with delicate strands and a deep, fragrant flavor. Raisins and candied citrus bring sweetness and a bright, almost sunny note to every slice.
Then comes a detail that can surprise first-time bakers: after baking, panettone is cooled upside down. The tender loaf is suspended so its tall dome keeps its shape instead of collapsing as it cools. A small act of patience, with a beautiful result.

This slow process is one reason panettone is best enjoyed unhurriedly. There is no need to rush the first slice. Let’s make coffee, gather everyone around, and take a moment.
Why do Sicilian bakers make some of the best panettone in Italy?
Panettone belongs to Milan, yet Sicilian bakers have become some of Italy’s most celebrated makers. Their approach feels familiar to us: begin with a classic, then bring in the ingredients that belong to your own roots.
Across Sicily, that can mean Bronte pistachio, Modica chocolate, and candied Sicilian citrus. Each addition tells a little story of place. The pistachio brings a rich, rounded nuttiness, the chocolate makes each bite deeper, and the citrus adds a bright, fragrant lift.
The result is not a contest between north and south. It is a conversation between traditions, a Milanese loaf with Sicilian character.
We met the owner of Fiasconaro in person, in San Francisco in 2025. The family built its name on Sicilian panettone, and hearing him talk through the mother yeast and the long, patient rise changed the way the bread tastes to us. Every slice since has carried the work behind it. For the fuller story of how a family from the island took on Italy’s most guarded Christmas bake, read La Cucina Italiana’s piece on panettone made in Sicily.

One history note: the origins of panettone are not settled. You will hear a Milanese tale of a kitchen helper who saves a dessert and gives the bread his name. It is a charming legend, not confirmed history. We like it as a holiday story, but the magic is in what bakers make today.

How do you choose and store a good panettone?
A good panettone should feel soft and fragrant, with a delicate, airy crumb, not dry or heavy. Look for a loaf made with natural leavening and butter, and check the ingredient list for the flavors you enjoy. Prefer the classic? Choose raisins and candied citrus. Want a Sicilian note? Look for versions with pistachio, chocolate, or island citrus.
If you would rather skip the candied fruit altogether, the shelves also carry pandoro, the star-shaped Christmas cake from Verona, and a pistachio-filled one has been selling fast this month.
Once you bring one home, follow the storage directions on its packaging. Keep it sealed in a cool, dry place before opening. After cutting, wrap it well to help protect its soft crumb and aroma. Panettone is at its best when shared, so invite a few friends, or keep a slice aside for tomorrow’s breakfast. No judgment.


How do you serve panettone the Sicilian way?
In Italy, panettone belongs to Christmas and New Year, often served with a sweet or sparkling wine. In Sicilian and southern Italian homes, it also turns up at breakfast, next to an espresso. That is one of our favorite ways to enjoy it: a slice, a small cup of coffee, and a quiet moment before the day begins.
That simple pairing is what we mean when we talk about Sicilian coffee culture. Good coffee is more than a drink. It is a pause, a small pleasure, a reason to sit together, and the whole point of il dolce far niente (the sweetness of doing nothing). At home, brew your espresso or moka and enjoy panettone as it is, soft and buttery, or toast a slice for crisp edges and a warm center.
That is the whole ritual, and it does not need improving. A slice on a plate, a small cup of coffee, and someone to sit with. Our holidays look like that, and so does most of December behind the counter.

What should you look for when you buy panettone online?
When you buy panettone online, buy from a shop that ships it in the box it was baked in, and read the ingredient list before you order. A loaf made with a mother yeast, butter and egg yolks, and no shortcut leavenings, is the one that will still taste soft on the day it arrives. Buy the coffee at the same time, because it matters as much as the bread: our Morettino beans are roasted in Palermo, where the family has been roasting since 1920.
Frequently asked questions
Is panettone the same as fruitcake? No. Panettone is naturally leavened and very light, with an airy crumb, while fruitcake is dense and heavy. About the only thing they share is dried fruit.
Should panettone be served warm or at room temperature? Both work. Serve it at room temperature for the softest crumb, or toast a slice briefly for crisp edges.
How should you store panettone after cutting it? Wrap it tightly and keep it in a cool, dry place, then follow the date on the packaging. Toasting is the best way to finish a loaf that is a few days old.
Do you sell panettone in your cafes? Yes, it is on the shelf at our Beverly Hills and Venice Beach locations during the holidays, and it is also available online.
Where to find it
Shipped nationwide at shop.castaneacafe.com, or pick one up and order ahead at our Beverly Hills cafe or our Venice Beach cafe.
Nando & Rose Benincasa are the husband-and-wife founders of Castanea Sicilian Cafe. Raised on childhood summers in Sicily, they brought Palermo’s espresso culture and Sicily’s pastry traditions to Los Angeles, with cafes in Beverly Hills and Venice Beach and Italian catering across LA.
